American Idol 10: Top 12 Girls
Thursday, March 3rd, 2011There are a lot of unknown (to me) faces in the lineup. As well as a lot of sequins and strapless dresses. They’re dolled up and ready to rock out! (And speaking of dolled up, what’s with J-Lo’s dress? Can we really call it a dress? It’s more of a big sparkly scarf wrapped around her. Fug!)
Tonight is going to consist of a lot of songs I don’t know, and a few that I think are going to be horrible, horrible mistakes. I’m looking at one item on the song list in particular.
The judges blah-blah, while I’m off in my own mental happy place. Then the girls come out, and seriously, for at least half of them I’m all, “Who?” And for a couple of them, I’m all, “Ugh.” Off we go!
1. Ta-Tynisa Wilson – “Only Girl in the World” – I think I only noticed this girl for the first time when she was told she made the top 24. She’s wearing a ’50s-style dress that would be more appropriate on someone doing the jive on a dancing show. And her singing is … all right, I guess. I mean, this is a terrible song. And parts of it are way too low for her. And her dancing is kind of a squatting-stomping combo. And her next-to-last big note is awful. The only good thing is that her necklace is made up of hidden Mickeys. Meh. Meeeeehhhhhh.

MICKEYS!
2. Naima Adedapo – “Summertime” – Throughout the preliminary rounds, we’ve been told over and over again how amazing this girl is. But I haven’t really seen it so far. Although she certainly does go all-out with her wardrobe. She’s doing a jazzed-up version of her song, and it’s … the best I’ve heard out of her. There are a couple of dud notes near the end, but overall it’s a good performance. She also looks comfortable on the stage, and really knows how to use the space. She still doesn’t quite rock my socks, but she’s totally moving on to the finals.
3. Kendra Chantelle – “Impossible” – Who? Who is this girl? She looks like someone else. Hmm. She certainly looks good in leather pants. She sounds fine, I suppose. I’m just really distracted by her sleepy eyes. Girl looks like she’s about to keel over with the narcolepsy. Plus she’s just standing there, and the song kind of plods along. She does some fair runs, but I just don’t know if she’ll stand out enough by the end of the night.
4. Rachel Zevita – “Criminal” – I’m worried about this one. This is the song that makes me fret. And OH MY GOD SHE’S RUINING IT. She turns the song into a jazzy nightmare, and apparently she doesn’t give a crap about the actual melody. Props for performance, since there’s a lot of “sexy” tromping around the stage and the judges’ platform. But it’s like she took the words to a song, then wrote completely new music around them. There’s nothing that relates to the original besides ONE key change. Ghastly. I know she’s the female pick this week for the Vote for the Worst gang, and I can totally see why.
5. Karen Rodriguez – “Hero” – Well, we’ve had the Xtina, now it’s time for Mariah. Why, oh why do these girls always try to tackle the bombastic divas? At least there’s no Celene Dion song tonight for the trifecta. She does switch it up by doing part of the song in Spanish, which will probably tickle J-Lo’s heart. Overall it’s good, but bland. There was just no excitement for me. The judges, however, loved the absolute crap out of it.
6. Lauren Turner – “Seven Day Fool” – Oh, okay, so there are two Laurens in this group. This is the one who I don’t recall ever having seen. (The other one irritates the hell out of me.) She continues the jazzy theme of the night, and it’s pretty good. I’ve learned from this Lauren that they make combat boots with a wedge heel. And that you shouldn’t go on national TV with a chipped manicure.

I mean, seriously. Look at those nails. If you’re going to wear the black nail polish like all the hip kids, you gotta keep that stuff up. Plus, does the bottom of the new AI microphone look like an electric stove burner? Or the MasterChef logo? Anyhoo, I’m filing this Lauren under “forgettable”.
7. Ashthon Jones – “Love All Over Me” – Oh no, this is a fashion don’t. The denim bustier with high-waisted black leggings? Bad, bad, BAD. I do love her hair, though. I don’t know this song, but I have to say, the line “I’ve got love all over me” sounds like a euphemism. I can’t be the only one whose inner 12-year-old is giggling away. And she keeps singing it over and over and over! The song doesn’t rock my world, but I guess she sings it okay.
8. Julie Zorrilla – “Breakaway” – I know this girl loves the petticoats, but this outfit is a bit too junior prom. She sounds like she’s slightly behind the beat throughout the verse. Oh, and on parts of the chorus too. I wish this song were in a different key — it’s like she’s constantly butting up against the low end of her register, where she doesn’t have much power. A couple of her big final notes clunk, and overall this is pretty sub-par compared to what she’s done through the preliminary rounds.
9. Haley Reinhart – “Fallin’” – Okay, I think this Haley is who Kendra reminds me of. Wavy blondes with distinctive chins.

Nothing alike? Or secret cousins? Oooh, “Secret Cousins” would be a great song title. Or even a band name. Hmm. Her singing is pretty good, but her performance stinks. A lot of squatting and vague pointing and hand-flailing. She could be twice as good if she just knew how to use the stage. But she takes a tough song and turns in a decent performance. Although she doesn’t exactly get raves from the judges.
10. Thia Megia – “Out Here on My Own” – I don’t usually think of Irene Cara songs when I think of 15-year-old singers. But this kid is no ordinary 15. It’s a ballad, and usually those bore the pants off of me, but she does a fantastic job with it. She has a great voice, and unlike so many other teenaged contestants on this show, she can put actual emotion into the song. Plus, she’s totally dressed in a cute and age-appropriate fashion. And she seems like a genuinely nice kid. What’s not to like? Finalist!
11. Lauren Alaina – “Turn on the Radio” – On the complete other end of the teen spectrum, there’s this girl. Seems like she’s trying to be grown up SO HARD, with the teased hair and attitude, that it turns me off. Plus, country. I think we all know how I feel about country. But she’s been highlighted throughout all of the prelims, and she’s the only country singer on the girls’ side, so she’ll probably make it to the finals. Plus, the judges fawn all over her.
12. Pia Toscano – “I’ll Stand by You” – She’s a cute girl who I only vaguely recall. I’m jealous of her hair. She does a fair enough job with her song, but The Pretenders just doesn’t translate well for me into the overblown beautiful-voice sound that so many Idol contestants have. She’s also parked behind a microphone stand the entire song, so there’s no motion to pep up the ballad. Everyone seems to love her, and she is in the headliner spot, so I’ll have to seriously consider her for the finals.
Watching the recaps, there are some real clunkers in there. And a lot of all right. As usual, I’m going to make my picks based partly on my opinions of their singing, and partly on how the producers have edited the audition rounds. Here are my picks for the 5 moving on:
Naima Adedapo
Karen Rodriguez
Thia Megia
Lauren Alaina
Pia Toscano
We’ll see how well I scored during tonight’s results. Next week: wild cards!













